Whether or not based on constitutional articles...
- Prova CESPE/CEBRASPE - PCDF - Escrivão de Polícia - 2020 - 27º Simulado
Investigation
The agencies and organizations responsible for criminal investigations in Brazil are, mainly, the Federal Police (as the name explains, act in the whole country) and the Civil Police (that act in each State).
The Federal Police investigate: (i) criminal offences against the political and the social order or to the detriment of property, services and interests of the Union and of its autonomous government entities and public companies (in one word, federal crimes), as well as other offences with interstate or international effects and requiring uniform repression as the law shall establish; (ii) illegal traffic of narcotics and like drugs, as well as smuggling, without prejudice to action by the treasury authorities and other government agencies in their respective areas of competence.
According to the Brazilian Constitution, it is incumbent upon the civil police, except for the competence of the Union, to investigate criminal offences, with the exception of military ones. In other words, the Civil Police investigate crimes adjudicated by the State Courts; the Federal Police, the crimes judged by the Federal Courts, the illegal traffic of narcotics and like drugs, smuggling and other offences with interstate or international effects requiring uniform repression as the law shall establish.
Also, there are other government agencies that investigate crimes in their respective areas of competence, although this is not their primary attribution. These agencies investigate when a criminal offence is discovered during the regular exercise of their legitimate functions. For instance: (i) The Environmental Agency is responsible for investigating offences related to the environment; (ii) Internal Revenue Service is responsible for investigating offences related with revenue frauds and other federal tax frauds; (iii) the Central Bank investigates financial crimes; (iv) the Securities and Exchange Commission of Brazil investigates offences in the securities market; (v) the COAF is the Brazil’s FIU - Financial Intelligence Unit - acting in anti-money laundering and countering the financing of terrorism activities.
As said above, these agencies are not focused primarily on investigating crimes. They do so when, while developing their activities, they realize that a crime has been committed. In general, at the end of their activities, these agencies communicate to the Prosecutor’s Office, sending the evidence that an offence has occurred. Sometimes, just with the information sent by these agencies, it is impossible to initiate an immediate prosecution, so the prosecutor can complement the investigations, or it is possible to order the police to continue the investigation.
The investigation conducted by the Police is made in a police enquiry ruled by a chief police officer or police commissioner. These agents are graduated from law school and conduct the police enquiry under the supervision of the prosecutor. The judge acts in the investigation exceptionally, just when it is necessary to restrict the suspect’s rights or guarantees.
In Brazil, in general, public prosecutors cannot command the above-mentioned investigative organizations directly in a criminal investigation, but can request investigatory procedures and the institution of a police investigation. Nonetheless, there are few good examples of Joint Venture investigations, the so called “Task Forces” (like the Banestado case, that investigated the financial crimes related to the Bank of Banestado, in the Brazilian State of Paraná, with great results), where the Prosecutors can command the agents of other agencies, although there is no regulation of the Task Forces in Brazil.
According to the Brazilian Constitution, among other institutional functions of the Public Prosecution, it is their task to initiate, exclusively, public criminal prosecution, under the terms of the law (article 129, I) and to exercise external control over police activities (article 129, VI). According to a part of the doctrine and the case law, based on these constitutional articles, it is possible for the prosecutors to conduct their own investigation, grounded in the implicit power theory. In fact, a lot of corruption cases and important crimes were solved because of the prosecutors’ investigations, bringing to court a lot of politicians and agents used to impunity. In general, the prosecutors’ investigations are more efficient and independent than the ones conducted by the police, especially because the police officers do not have independence in their investigations and can be taken off the case by their superior, which is impossible when it comes to prosecutors.
On the other hand, a part of the doctrine dissents about the possibility of prosecutor’s investigation, based on the alleged abuses committed by the prosecution and the lack of legal regulation about the subject. In fact, there is no legal regulation about investigations conducted by the public prosecutors. Despite that discussion, it is common for prosecutors to investigate a lot of crimes on their own, especially crimes committed by police agents and corruption, with very good results. In this sense, to regulate these activities, there is a resolution (the level of which is below law) by the National Council of the Public Prosecution that regulates the investigation made by the prosecutors. When the Prosecutor directly makes the investigation, he may interview the suspects and key witnesses directly. Furthermore, he is authorized to access public databases, to require information, exams, expert examination and documents from public and private authorities and request the police force to help the investigation.
Source: http://www.mpf.mp.br/atuacao-tematica/sci/dados-daatuacao/links-tematicos/the-criminal-justice-system-in-brazil-abrief-account (adapted)
Based on the text above, judge the following items.
Whether or not based on constitutional articles, prosecutors may conduct their own investigations due to the lack of legal regulation about the subject.

Esta é uma questão inédita. Assine um de nossos planos para desbloqueá-la.
Enquanto questões de concursos anteriores mostram o que já caiu, as questões inéditas ajudam você a treinar o que pode cair agora.
Treine com conteúdos novos e atualizados
Identifique lacunas antes do dia da prova
Pare de acertar por memória e teste seu conhecimento de verdade