The phrase “state of affairs” is a general term used to
- Prova FGV - Câmara dos Deputados - Analista Legislativo - Área: Enfermeiro Conhecimentos Gerais - Pós-Edital - 2023 - 3º Simulado
Why Progressives Should Heed Obama's Call on Israel/ Palestine
Nov 07, 2023
1 When former president Barack Obama speaks on
an issue as contentious as Israel/Palestine, he is bound
to make the headlines. So it was following his remarks
last week, first in an Obama Foundation Democracy
5 Forum speech, then in a more candid sit-down
interview with a podcast. Along broadly predictable
lines, he denounced "decades of failure to achieve a
durable peace for both Israelis and Palestinians," he
called for an "admission of complexity" in the conflict,
he criticized "TikTok activism" as ineffectual and he
10 reminded us that we are all "complicit" in the conflict,
himself included.
The reactions were also predictable. Senate
minority leader Mitch McConnel attacked him as
equating Israel with Hamas, and Newsmax headlined
15 attacks on "Obama's neutrality on Israel." On the
other side, some "TikTok activists" naturally took
offense. One shouted at Obama that Hamas was a
"resistance group" not a terrorist group and that she
20 "didn't want to talk about Hamas" at all, rather proving
Obama's point.
Even beyond the fringes of TikTok, one can expect
most progressives to shrug at Obama's comments as
useless milquetoast oratory, all the more rageful as
25 they come in the midst of a war that is killing thousands
of Palestinians in Gaza. His call for "complexity" will
especially anger those whose political imagination
is, in principle, based on sharp delineations between
good and evil. Obama will be rebuffed for the same
30 reason that another well-known commentator was
celebrated a few days before. Speaking to Democracy
Now, Ta Nehisi-Coates won accolades not just for
his rightful denouncement of Israel's system of
segregation in the West Bank but for his insistence
35 that there was nothing complex about this conflict.
Coates surely has a point. There are many aspects
of life in Israel/Palestine that are indeed crystal clear
from any reasonable ethical standpoint: Millions
of Palestinians live in the West Bank as an occupied
population under the military rule of a foreign state
40 that enjoys the backing of most major Western states,
even as it no longer even pretends to want to end
this state of affairs. No comparable situation exists
anywhere in the world today.
But the complexity begins when we look at
45 history and all aspects of the conflict–and when it
comes to the daunting task of wanting to solve it. It is
here that we would do well to heed Obama's call.
The former president called for holding of
"seemingly contradictory ideas": that the Hamas
5 attack was horrific and absolutely unjustifiable—and
also that the occupation and the brutal war waged by
Israel on Gaza was unbearable—and also that "history
of the Jewish people" can't be dismissed. One could
55 add many more to the list.
More importantly, just as he criticized the
TikTokification of Israel/Palestine advocacy, Obama
reminded us of a simple but powerful truth: that
it's easy to "maintain moral innocence" but that this
"won't solve the problem." This is a call that should be
60 taken seriously, not just by those who failed any basic
ethical tests by refusing to condemn the terror attacks
of Hamas but by those who seem to think taking a
clear moral stance is enough.
65 Unlike what many self-righteous activists seem
to think, insisting on your moral superiority and
constantly comparing yourself to hallowed movements
of the past, from civil rights struggle in the U.S. to anti-
Apartheid fight in South Africa, doesn't bring change
70 to the real world. Obama acknowledged this when he
said, "If you genuinely want to change this, you got to
figure out how to listen to someone on the other side
and not dismiss it."
These words will surely be derided by many as
vacuous centrism, but they indeed contain a great
75 truth: that conflicts come to an end by bridging chasms
between people, not by ignoring them; that true
moral and political courage is sometimes in seeking
compromise—not intransigence at all costs.
80 Activists on the Left would do well to drop the
moral certitude and Manicheanism and adopt the
complexity called for by Obama. As we well remember
long years of imprisonment and suffering by heroes like
Nelson Mandela, we'd also do well to remember the
85 hard work that they did to build bridges to "the other
side," to call on their own sides to make the necessary
compromises so that peace could be possible.
When it comes to Israel/Palestine, this means
recognition of perspectives and national rights of both
90 communities living in that land: Palestinian Arabs and
Israeli Jews.
Any perspective not rooted in such recognition
will be something worse than unethical; it will be
ineffectual. As Obama rightly said, no child will be
95 saved by such an attitude.
Arash Azizi is a senior lecturer in history and political
science at Clemson University and author of the upcoming
"What Iranians Want: Women, Life, Freedom" (2024).
Source: https://www.newsweek.com/why-progressives-should-heed-
obamas-call-israel-palestine-opinion-1841560
The phrase “state of affairs” is a general term used to

Esta é uma questão inédita. Assine um de nossos planos para desbloqueá-la.
Enquanto questões de concursos anteriores mostram o que já caiu, as questões inéditas ajudam você a treinar o que pode cair agora.
Treine com conteúdos novos e atualizados
Identifique lacunas antes do dia da prova
Pare de acertar por memória e teste seu conhecimento de verdade